1. Medtech Insight
  2. >>Policy & Regulation
  3. >>Regulation

510(k) Data Debated In Comments On FDA Draft Guidance

Device companies say non-clinical data should be given more prominence in FDA guidance on benefit-risk factors to consider when determining substantial equivalence of 510(k) devices with different technological characteristics from a predicate. But a coalition of consumer groups argues that the draft guidance underplays the need for clinical data.

Disagreement between industry and consumer groups over the frequency that clinical trial data should form the basis of a 510(k) for a device with different technological characteristics from the predicate was evident in comments submitted on a recent FDA draft guidance.

Device companies say non-clinical data should be given more prominence in the final version of the guidance on benefit-risk factors...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Medtech Insight for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required
Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber?

More from Regulation

Medtech Giants Brace for Tariffs Impact: Responses Range From Financial To Philosophical

 
• By Marion Webb, Shubham Singh, and Nancy Pham

Manufacturing shifts, financial planning, and supply chain changes are among the adjustments that medtech leaders are making to Trump-era tariffs. Medtech Insight’s review of first-quarter earnings calls reveals how firms are navigating the impact and uncertainty of evolving trade policies.

Final Curtain For LDTs? FDA Will Not Appeal District Court Decision To Vacate Final Rule

 
• By Brian Bossetta

The US FDA has given up on its effort to regulate lab-developed tests as medical devices, at least for now. The agency will not appeal a decision from the Eastern District of Texas that tossed out the FDA’s final rule, leaving the agency with few cards.

EU Finalizes Framework For Joint Clinical Assessments Of High-Risk Devices

 
• By Amanda Maxwell

Second submission window for joint scientific consultations on a procedure to help prepare for joint clinical assessments will open from 2 to 30 June 2025.

UK Take Care! Regulatory And Market Access Reforms Must Not Shut Out Medtech Growth

 
• By Ashley Yeo

Speakers at a recent UK medtech outlook conference voiced optimism about the sector’s prospects, but warned that cost burdens, over-regulation and lengthy processes will impede the capacity of local SMEs to innovate. Only 10% of NHS procured medtech comes from UK manufacturers.

More from Policy & Regulation

‘Dawn Of FDA’s AI Era’ Has Arrived. Makary Announces Early Implentation Of ‘Elsa’ Platform

 
• By Brian Bossetta

US FDA Commissioner Marty Makary says the agency’s generative AI tool ‘Elsa’ will allow employees across the FDA to work more efficiently. The commissioner says Elsa’s launch comes ahead of schedule following a successful pilot program.

Medtech Experts Debate EU Recertification Gridlock

 
• By Amanda Maxwell

Modifying or doing away with the EU medtech recertification requirement is far from straightforward. Four experts from an EU national authority, an EU notified body trade association and industry, plus a well-known medtech consultant, reflect on how to move forward.

DeepLook AI Imaging Provides A Deeper Look At Dense Breast

 
• By Brian Bossetta

DeepLook Medical recently announced the commercial rollout of DL Precise, an AI-powered imaging platform that enhances breast cancer screening, at major healthcare institutions across the US.