US Supreme Court Limits Estoppel Rule In Minerva Surgical v. Hologic

The ruling keeps the principle of assignor estoppel in place, but limits its use to situations where an inventor’s claims in court directly contradict those in the patent.

Supreme Court and patents

The US Supreme Court preserved but narrowed an inventor’s right to later argue that their patent is not valid in Minerva Surgical v. Hologic, the second high court case this month to involve the medical device industry.

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Medtech Insight for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Legal & IP

US Medtech Tariffs: How Will EU Navigate Unchartered Territory?

 

US President Trump has imposed sweeping tariffs that encompass medtech. These are expected to drive up costs, disrupt supply chains and hinder innovation, likely driving the EU to seek new trade partnerships to mitigate the impact.

Democrats Condemn Trump’s HHS Layoffs During House Hearing On OTC Drug User Fees

 

Energy and Commerce Health Subcommittee Democrats focus on criticizing HHS Secretary Kennedy’s RIF announcement, including 3,500 FDA jobs among cuts across HHS agencies. Representatives were left wondering if user fee programs would continue, even if reauthorized.

LDT Saga Comes To A Grinding Halt As Judge Sides With Labs, Vacates FDA’s Final Rule

 

A federal judge in Texas delivered what is most likely a fatal blow to the US FDA’s final rule, which would have regulated lab-developed tests as medical devices.

US Federal Trade Commission Challenges Surmodics-Biocoat Merger Over Antitrust Concerns

 
• By 

A planned merger between medical device coating manufacturers Surmodics and Biocoat is facing an antitrust lawsuit from the US Federal Trade Commission. The FTC believes the move would create an illegal monopoly.

More from Policy & Regulation

Trump’s Preliminary 2026 HHS Budget Plan Protects US FDA User Fee Collection

 
• By 

The preliminary White House 2026 budget plan cuts agency funding, but not so sharply that user fees are excluded from collection.

Abbott, J&J Reaffirm 2025 Profit Guidance Despite Growing Tariff Uncertainties

 
• By 

Abbott and J&J reassured investors they will maintain their 2025 profit forecasts. Abbott projects $5.05 to $5.25 per share and plans a new $500m investment in manufacturing and R&D sites. J&J anticipates $400m in tariff-related costs but committed $55bn in US investment over four years.

Congress, Researchers Highlight Security Risks At DNA Testing Services

 
• By 

Congress has launched an inquiry into 23andMe amid privacy concerns following its bankruptcy, particularly regarding the potential sale of sensitive user data. Additionally, a Cybernews report gave 40 DNA testing firms an average cybersecurity grade of D, citing widespread vulnerabilities and data breaches, along with inadequate public information about their security practices.