Accelerated Approval: US FDA Defends Size Of Premarket Safety Databases, Confirmatory Endpoints

Taking on critics who say it is too quick to award accelerated approval based on surrogate endpoints and limited safety data, agency's 25-year review shows cancer drugs receiving accelerated approval generally have twice the amount of safety data as efficacy, and more than half have confirmed clinical benefit after approval.

Medical book with Stethoscope

Safety databases for new molecular entity oncology and hematology drug indications approved under accelerated approval are, on average, twice the size of the efficacy databases, US FDA staff say in a review article published online in JAMA Oncology March 1.

The review, which takes a data-driven look at the agency's use of the accelerated approval mechanism for cancer treatments over...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Pink Sheet for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Approval Standards

Complete Response Letter Trio Raises Prospect Of Tidal Shift In Regenerative Medicine Regulation

 

Replimune's RP1 oncolytic immunotherapy became the third regenerative medicine to receive an FDA complete response letter this month as the agency appears to re-visit previous agreements about accelerated approval.

Don’t Look Back: US FDA AdComm Offers No Flexibility For Rexulti’s Post Hoc Bid In PTSD

 

The US FDA's Psychopharmacology Advisory Committee emphasized high standards over regulatory flexibility while turning down Otsuka's brexpiprazole plus serotonin for post-traumatic stress disorder based on conflicting Phase III trials and post-hoc Phase II analyses.

Slowdown: US FDA’s 2025 Novel Approvals Are On Below-Average Pace

 

US FDA's 25 novel approvals in 2025 fell short of the agency's five-year average count, driven by a drop in drugs center approvals; 45 user fee goals remain in second half of year.

US FDA Asking Questions About Commissioner’s Voucher Program With Details Scarce

 

FDA staff are trying to plan for program implementation in the absence of critical eligibility and other details, although guidance may be coming soon.

More from Pathways & Standards

US FDA’s Second Half 2025 User Fee Goals Swing Toward Respiratory Disease

 

The 43 novel agents with user fee goal dates in the remainder of 2025 have fewer oncologics and infectious disease drugs than the first half of the year.

Consumer Groups Have A ‘Radical Transparency’ List For US FDA’s PDUFA VIII

 

Development of the user fee commitment letter largely takes place behind closed doors between industry and FDA. Outside groups see the upcoming negotiation cycle as a chance to change this and other agency information blocks by reminding Commissioner Makary of his commitment to transparency.

Senate Bill Would Boost Oversight Of US FDA User Fee Program Following Trump Reorganization

 

Senate appropriators also put FDA on notice regarding recent meetings and compliance with the Federal Advisory Committees Act, signal positive news on rare pediatric diseases, and offer hints of other agency areas they have close eyes on.