Stock Watch: Risk And The Pharmaceutical Discount Rate

Track Records May Not Be Reflected Even In Risk-Adjusted Valuations

In contrast to the SEC’s view that public companies’ regulatory filings give investors all the information needed to make an investment decision, the discount rate used to value a company may not reflect all its risks.

Stock Watch Image, Andy Smith
ANDY SMITH OFFERS A LIFE SCIENCE INVESTOR'S PERSPECTIVE ON BIOPHARMA BUSINESS

I listened to a discussion recently on the discount rates used to value pharmaceutical and biotechnology products. One of the speakers suggested that the same asset should have a higher value (via a lower discount rate) if it were being developed by Pfizer Inc.* for example, than by a smaller biotech company. This is logical because an asset in an area where Pfizer has therapeutic and commercial expertise should have better quality resources behind it and Pfizer’s previous experience in that therapeutic area should also increase the chances of success. In addition, a new product enlarging an existing therapeutic portfolio at Pfizer has the advantage of not building out a de novo commercial infrastructure at a smaller biotech company. However, I wondered if these assumptions were always true and if enough track-record risk is captured in company valuations.

When Pfizer acquired Biohaven Pharmaceutical Holding Company Ltd. for $11.6bn in May 2022, it was largely to gain its...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Scrip for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Stock Watch

Stock Watch: How GSK’s Nucala Info Drip Helped Share Price

 
• By 

The information flow in the months before the approval of GSK’s Nucala in COPD provides an interesting case study, and brings to mind the cautionary tale of Alnylam’s Onpattro.

Stock Watch: Q1 Sales Trends And Forex Muddle Pharma Outlook

 
• By 

Pharma firms tended to downplay first-quarter trends in full-year guidance. However, raised guidance seems fragile amid ongoing foreign exchange effects and Medicare Part D redesign pressures.

Stock Watch: Bayer, Bavarian Nordic Bring European Cheer To Pharma

 
• By 

Investors welcomed Bavarian Nordic’s and Bayer’s earnings announcements. However, both stock prices declined over the day of their reports as the impact of recent pressures weighed.

Stock Watch: Stock Watch: Lilly And Novo Duke Out Q1

 
• By 

Novo Nordisk enjoyed a surprise GLP-1 agonist contracting win in the first quarter of 2025. This provided a welcome boost to its stock after it had spent the previous quarter on the back foot against rival Lilly.

More from Business

Will Pfizer Walk Away From Arvinas After PROTAC Disappointment?

 

Arvinas and Pfizer have just filed the potential first-in-class protein degrader vepdegestrant, but its diminished commercial prospects after mixed Phase III data mean Pfizer could exit.

Finance Watch: Vera Raises Debt, Taysha And Trevi Price Offering After Big Trial Wins

 
• By 

Public Company Edition: Public company funding in 2025 is down from 2024, but after recent positive data readouts Vera accessed up to $450m in new debt, while Taysha and Trevi grossed $200m and $100m, respectively, in stock offerings. Meanwhile, Keros, Stealth and others cut jobs.

A MoonLake Buyout Would Boost Merck & Co’s Immunology Ambitions

 

As the patent protection clock ticks down on Merck’s flagship blockbuster Keytruda, the company is reported to be pursuing the inflammation and immunology biotech. Such a move would bulk up its sparse I&I pipeline.