Lawsuits To Stop FDA From Overseeing LDTs Could Create Chaos, Panelist Says

As the 6 May deadline to implement the FDA’s final rule on lab-developed tests approaches, attempts to stop the rule from taking effect are set to play out in court. A panel of experts discussed the potential impact of these legal efforts, should they be successful, at the Medtech Conference in Toronto.

Nathan Brown and Carly McWilliams speak during a session on LDT regulations at the Medtech Conference in Toronto, Ontario, on 16 October.
Nathan Brown and Carly McWilliams speak during a session on LDT regulations at the Medtech Conference in Toronto, Ontario, on 16 October. (Brian Bossetta/Citeline)

When Congress at the end of 2022 failed to pass the VALID Act that would have establishing perimeters for the US Food and Drug Administration to regulate laboratory developed tests, it set in motion a chain of events that could spell pandemonium.

Key Takeaways

Ongoing lawsuits could upend the LDT industry, potentially leading to renewed interest in Congressional action.

The outcome will depend on the exact language of legal rulings, as well as actions taken under a new administration.

Scott Garrett, a partner in medtech-focused investment firm Water Street Healthcare Partners, believes some criticisms of the final rule are misguided.

More from Medtech Insight

SS Innovations’ SSI Mantra 3 Poised To Challenge Da Vinci In Robotic Surgery Market

 
• By 

SS Innovations reported its first SSi Mantra 3 robotic cardiac surgery in South America as it prepares to file for US FDA de novo clearance and a CE mark. The firm aims to challenge Intuitive Surgical with a lower-cost, flexible system targeting US and European markets.

Innovative Wants Injunction Against J&J Subsidiary After $442M Antitrust Verdict

 
• By 

Innovative Healthcare is asking for a permanent injunction against Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Biosense Webster after winning a $442 million antitrust verdict. The injunction aims to prevent continued anticompetitive practices in the electrophysiology catheter market.

Philips Deals Itself A Strong Hand In POCUS Stakes

 
• By 

Point of care ultrasound technology that can be used by non-sonographers will plug gaps in workforce coverage and bring new critical care capabilities to the frontline of care, said Royal Philips.

Liquid Biopsy Startup Mursla Bio Launches AI Precision Medicine Platform

 

The new AI Precision Medicine platform supports the company’s flagship product, EvoLiver, which received US FDA breakthrough device designation in April.

More from Compliance

Global Medtech Guidance Tracker: May 2025

 
• By 

Stay current on regulatory guidelines from around the world with Medtech Insight's Guidance Tracker. Thirty-six documents have been posted on the tracker since its last update.

FDA Rebukes Four Companies, Including One Overseas, For Procedural Failures

 

The US FDA’s device center sent warning letters to three domestic device manufacturers and one German firm for failing to adhere to protocol on several issues.

Get Ready For International Harmonization Before Approaching QMSR Deadline, Says Regulatory Expert

 

During MD&M East last week, regulatory consultant Darren Reeves reminded device manufacturers that the time to get ready to comply with the new Quality Management System Regulation is now.