Texas Justice and the Industry's Image

With its $253 million judgment against Merck & Co. Inc. (reduced to $26.1 million under Texas law), the jury "sent a message" about what it perceived as the pharmaceutical industry's culture of greed. Ironically Merck's liability gives it a rare opportunity to right the ship. But will industry's tarnished image impede the approval and use of Merck's most important upcoming product, the HPV vaccine Gardasil?

It would be tough to claim that the Texas jury's decision in favor of the woman who claimed her husband was killed by rofecoxib (Vioxx) reflected medical truth. But the fact that Robert Ernst probably didn't die of a heart attack—much less one that was caused by Vioxx—was beside the point. With its $253 million judgment against Merck & Co. Inc. (reduced to $26.1 million under Texas law), the jury "sent a message" about what it perceived as the pharmaceutical industry's culture of greed.

The industry is unlikely to hear that message: its executives simply don't believe it. Too often we've heard them dismiss the broader importance of the jury's message by blaming Merck's lawyers for failing to win on the facts. And the lawyers were probably guilty as charged

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on In Vivo for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Leadership

More from In Vivo

NewAmsterdam’s Davidson On Reviving “Failed” Drug Class To Fill Cardiovascular Treatment Gap

 
• By 

After a string of high-profile failures by big pharma, Michael Davidson is positioning his company's CETP inhibitor as the next breakthrough in cardiovascular medicine. The body of data to support this position is growing.

Dealmaking Quarterly Statistics, Q1 2025

 
• By 

During Q1, biopharma M&A deal value reached $38.4bn and drew in $60.8bn in potential deal value from alliances. Device company M&A values reached $8.7bn.

Rising Leaders 2025: Flagship’s Jacob Rubens On Building The Next Generation Of Biotech

 
• By 

Rising Leader Jacob Rubens, who has co-founded and led several Flagship companies and is now origination partner, believes aspiring leaders should follow their bliss.