California Court’s Inaction On TiO2 Prop 65 First Amendment Case Breeds New Lawsuits

The Personal Care Products Council seeks to stem the rising tide of titanium dioxide Proposition 65 lawsuits, requesting that a California court prohibit the state’s Attorney General and private enforcers from filing and/or prosecuting new suits against cosmetics companies failing to warn about potential TiO2 exposure.

zombies
Private enforcer lawsuits are on the rise as PCPC's motion for preliminary injunction remains pending in California's Eastern District. • Source: Shutterstock

Titanium dioxide preliminary violation notices and lawsuits from Proposition 65 private enforcers have ballooned in the last six months, following a motion from the Personal Care Products Council that asked a California court to halt enforcement action on such cases while it assesses if required titanium dioxide cancer warnings on cosmetic products violate companies’ First Amendment rights.

More from Legal

Uncertainty Abounds With SEC Climate Reporting Rule Tied Up In Courts

 
• By 

Despite questions surrounding the SEC rule, including disputes being litigated in the US Eighth Circuit, companies must prepare to meet the new climate disclosure requirements in addition to related mandates in California and abroad. Experts emphasize opportunities beyond compliance.

In Emergency Rule, California Bans All THCs In Hemp Products: Industry Asks, Where’s The Fire?

 

California authorities say predominance of retailers licensed to sell hemp are compliant with ban published effective on 3 October through emergency regulation. But hemp industry’s contesting the regulation in state court, arguing state authorities inappropriately used emergency action to change state law on hemp products legislature passed in 2021.

J&J Sued For ‘Plant-Based’ Claims On Aveeno, Neutrogena Makeup Removing Wipes

 
• By 

Plaintiffs in California federal courts seek restitution, damages, and other relief on behalf of themselves and consumers nationwide, whom allegedly were deceived by “Plant-Based” representations on Aveeno and Neutrogena Makeup Removing Wipes.

US FDA Action On Benzene Levels In Acne Products Demanded By New Citizen Petition

 
• By 

Filed on 20 August by Pensacola, FL-based law firm Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis & Overholtz (AWKO) on behalf of an unnamed client, the petition points to benzene study data unconnected to Valisure on unheated benzoyl peroxide products, but is light on details of how it was conducted.

More from Policy & Regulation

CIR Panel Finds Two Hair Dye Ingredients Safe, But Not For Skin, Eyes Or Lashes

 
• By 

Data from the US Food and Drug Administration indicated that two hair dye ingredients are formulated in eye makeup and dermal application products, prompting a Cosmetic Ingredient Review panel to conclude one dye is unsafe for such uses and discouraging those uses in the other dye.

No Longer Voluntary, MoCRA Drives Drastic Increase In Registered Companies, Products

 
• By 

Preliminary registration data released by FDA offers a first glimpse of the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act’s impact on information the agency has at hand.

Beauty Counterfeit Market Continues Surging On Fast-Evolving Criminal Rings

 
• By 

Counterfeit beauty products cost the US industry an estimated $3bn in 2023, says a trade expert during the Personal Care Products Council’s Beauty Collective Summit.