1. HBW Insight
  2. >>Wellness
  3. >>Policy & Regulation
  4. >>Legal

Another Court Ruling Rejects RCT Standard For Supplement Claims

 
• By Eileen Francis

Two years after Bayer prevailed against FTC's demand for RCTs to substantiate claims for its Phillips Colon Health probiotic, a judge dismisses a class action complaint targeting the product, saying the plaintiffs did not support their argument and their expert expected supplements to be evaluated as drugs.

court house

A ruling on a class action complaint targeting Bayer HealthCare LLC's Phillips Colon Health probiotic, like an earlier decision on the Federal Trade Commission's challenge of the same product, says that clinical trials are not required to substantiate a dietary supplement claim.

In US District Court for the New Jersey District, Judge John Vazquez granted a motion attorneys for the Bayer AG business filed in May 2016 to dismiss the complaint filed in 2011 by consumers in California and Illinois

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on HBW Insight for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required
Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber?

More from Legal

NAD Asks FTC To Pull Bandage Off Firm’s Plan To Exhaust Inventory Using ‘2X Faster Healing’ Claim

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

After National Advertising Division attorneys, in a review prompted by a challenge by Band-Aid line marketer Kenvue, recommended ASO LLV cease use of its “up to 2x faster healing” claim, they determined the firm had not fully complied.

Supreme Court 1935 Ruling Limiting Executive Authority On Appointments ‘Unravels’ Today – DoJ

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

In complaint and response to motion to dismiss, Rebecca Kelly Slaughter’s and Alvaro Bedoya’s attorneys elaborate on Supreme Court ‘s 1935 decision, Humphrey’s Executor v. US. Administration attorneys, though, contend the ruling isn’t relevant to the current FTC.

Loper Bright Could Trip FDA On Self-Affirmed GRAS

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

Instead of arguing FDA’s not authorized to offer option under authority from 1958 Food Additives Amendments, potential litigation could contend the law requires agency to continue making self-GRAS without notification available.

EU Probiotics Deadlock: Ombudsman Finds ‘No Maladministration’ By The Commission

 
• By David Ridley

In response to an IPA Europe complaint, European Ombudsman Emily O’Reilly finds that the Commission’s interpretation of EU food legislation in relation to probiotics is “reasonable and in line with the main goal of this legislation, which is to ensure a high level of consumer protection.”

More from Policy & Regulation

Third-Party ‘Testing, Inspection and Certification’ Cleaning Up Amazon Supplement Market

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

Three FDA warnings related to supplement manufacturing, labeling or marketing submitted to Amazon or companies selling vitamin, mineral or supplement products on its e-commerce platform since April 2024.

Digital Services Deliver Hemp, States Deliver Regulation With Congress Yet To Act

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

Four months into session, no bills have been introduced in Congress to authorize FDA to establish a regulatory pathway for the lawful use of hemp ingredients in products other than drugs or propose some other solution to the federal conundrum present since lawmakers in 2018 de-scheduled hemp.

Little Industry Opposition To FDA Plan To Remove Synthetic Dyes, Or Agreement They’re Unsafe

 
• By Malcolm Spicer

Dyes and colors which FDA says industries agree should no longer be used aren’t unsafe and are currently used only with the agency’s approval, industry stakeholders say. Center for Science in the Public Interest says the dyes are used “in tens of thousands of foods and beverages that are commonly consumed here in the United States.”