Some stakeholders are critical of ISO 16128 because it doesn't set a minimum threshold for natural or organic content in so-labeled products or include an ingredient blacklist. But Cosmetics Europe says it's up to regulators to build on the ISO guidelines with rules for product claims, and private standards banning ingredients in line with consumer "values" can continue to serve more discriminating shoppers.
Cosmetics Europe says criticism of the recently finalized ISO standard for natural and organic ingredients may be due to misunderstanding regarding the development process and aims.
Moreover, "from the beginning when we discussed what we wanted from the guidelines, we always said they should be based on science," a spokesperson for the trade group told the...