FDA’s Quest For More MDR Exemption Requests Leaves Device Industry Jittery
• By Shawn M. Schmitt
A draft Medical Device Reporting guidance from FDA has concerned industry experts who say the document would require manufacturers to spend an onerous amount of time submitting requests for exemption to the agency’s MDR regulation. The draft removes a longstanding so-called “two-year rule” for reporting, calls for firms and contract manufacturers to jointly seek exemptions, and asks companies to file an exemption request after selling a 510(k). Close observers suggest the agency is proposing the modifications to make it clearer to agency investigators and companies when MDRs are in fact required. FDA also likely wants to maximize the useful post-market information it receives rather than cutting off MDR reports superficially, outside attorneys explain. But some experts argue the increased emphasis on exemptions would add more burden to companies and FDA with little benefit.
Manufacturers would have to file a flurry of requests to exempt themselves from Medical Device Reporting obligations if FDA finalizes a draft guidance that aims to tighten the agency’s reins on MDR activities, legal experts say.
With new regulations limiting the use of plastics popping up worldwide, the medtech industry sees arguments on both sides. Some argue hasty bans of PFAS ("forever chemicals") would harm patients, while others say phthalates should be phased out to protect the public.
Ahead of the 11 June UK spending review and its anticipated funding uplift for healthcare and life sciences, the MHRA announced an expansion of its digital expertise by creating a dedicated hub in Leeds, a renowned center of medtech excellence.
Manufacturing shifts, financial planning, and supply chain changes are among the adjustments that medtech leaders are making to Trump-era tariffs. Medtech Insight’s review of first-quarter earnings calls reveals how firms are navigating the impact and uncertainty of evolving trade policies.
Preparations for the reauthorization of the Medical Device User Fee Amendments for 2028-2032 are underway, with the US FDA announcing a public meeting for 4 August. After negotiations with industry and other stakeholders, a draft agreement is due to Congress by 15 January 2025.
Robert Foster, HHS deputy general counsel and chief counsel for food, research and drugs, is temporarily heading the Office of Chief Counsel, but a permanent appointee is expected after Michael Stuart's confirmation as HHS general counsel.
The US FDA recently published a draft guidance document for manufacturers of mesh products that are used during several types of hernia repair procedures.
