Theranos Cases Show How DoJ Looks Beyond The FDCA In Prosecuting Drug, Device Companies

Charges under wire fraud statute carry higher maximum prison sentences and are easier to explain than FDCA misbranding charges, Department of Justice officials say in dissecting the guilty verdicts and lengthy prison sentences for former leaders of the failed blood testing start-up.

Man with telescope
Department of Justice is increasingly looking beyond the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act in bringing criminal charges against regulated companies. • Source: Shutterstock

Guilty verdicts and lengthy prison sentences for the two former leaders of the failed blood testing start-up Theranos Inc. show the advantage for prosecutors in bringing charges outside the federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act, current and former Department of Justice officials said.

Allegations of fraud and conspiracy involving firms and products regulated by the Food and Drug Administration can be easier for...

More from Legal & IP

Former Top OIG Attorney Gives Inside Look At Fraud Prevention

 
• By 

Former HHS-OIG attorney Rob DeConti emphasized the significance of data analytics and compliance in combating healthcare fraud, urging medical tech companies to adopt robust measures to prevent potential risks.

DME And Diagnostics In Crosshairs As DOJ ‘Follows The Money’

 
• By 

The DOJ has launched nearly 70 enforcement actions in 2025, targeting diagnostics, durable medical equipment, and telehealth fraud. Key cases involve significant fraudulent claims against Medicare, with individuals facing severe penalties.

Mexico’s New Procurement Rules Aim To Increase Healthcare Investment, But May Face Legal Trouble

 

Legal experts warn, however, that new Mexican procurement rules are discriminatory and could be challenged in the courts.

Innovative Wants Injunction Against J&J Subsidiary After $442M Antitrust Verdict

 
• By 

Innovative Healthcare is asking for a permanent injunction against Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Biosense Webster after winning a $442 million antitrust verdict. The injunction aims to prevent continued anticompetitive practices in the electrophysiology catheter market.

More from Policy & Regulation

EU Authorities Unite In Call For Urgent Overhaul Of Medtech Regulations

 

EU member states have issued a consensus statement on the urgent need to build momentum to tackle governance and centralization issues as part of much-needed reform of the EU medtech regulatory system.

Whoops! FDA Says Company Marketed Unauthorized Device. The Company Says The FDA Is Wrong

 

A recent FDA warning letter claims a Boston firm that specializes in wearable technology marketed a blood pressure device without agency approval. The company rejects the assertion and says the agency is out of step with federal law.

With CMS Coverage Established, Medtronic Looks To Next Steps For Renal Denervation

 
• By 

US Medicare has proposed national coverage of renal denervation for patients with uncontrolled hypertension. The treatment is seeing other advances as well, with Medtronic piloting a longer catheter and a multi-organ approach and a blood test to identify the best candidates fresh on the