1. Medtech Insight
  2. >>Policy & Regulation
  3. >>Legal & IP

Companies Targeted By FTC Using Penalty Offense Authority Have Strong Defense, Attorney Says

 
• By Eileen Francis

John Villafranco, partner at Kelly Drye & Warren LLP, says the US FTC’s ability to obtain monetary relief using the penalty offense mechanism is questionable both on statutory and Constitutional grounds. Marketers faced with civil penalties – for example, for alleged inadequately substantiated health claims – should stand their ground, he suggests in a recent interview.

Medtech, personal care and other companies faced with potential civil penalties under the US Federal Trade Commission’s penalty offense authority have a strong defense on both statutory and Constitutional grounds, says John Villafranco, partner at Kelley Drye & Warren LLP.

“If a company were to litigate, I believe it could successfully assert a number of defenses,” Villafranco said in a...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Medtech Insight for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required
Start Free Trial

Already a subscriber?

More from Legal & IP

FDA Document Request Denied As Case Against SurModics Merger Intensifies

 
• By Elizabeth Orr

A federal court in Illinois ruled against SurModics and BC Holdings' request for FDA documents to support a proposed merger. The FTC has challenged the merger, claiming it threatens competition in hydrophilic device coatings. The ruling may indicate the FTC is likely to succeed.

Former Top OIG Attorney Gives Inside Look At Fraud Prevention

 
• By Elizabeth Orr

Former HHS-OIG attorney Rob DeConti emphasized the significance of data analytics and compliance in combating healthcare fraud, urging medical tech companies to adopt robust measures to prevent potential risks.

DME And Diagnostics In Crosshairs As DOJ ‘Follows The Money’

 
• By Elizabeth Orr

The DOJ has launched nearly 70 enforcement actions in 2025, targeting diagnostics, durable medical equipment, and telehealth fraud. Key cases involve significant fraudulent claims against Medicare, with individuals facing severe penalties.

Mexico’s New Procurement Rules Aim To Increase Healthcare Investment, But May Face Legal Trouble

 
• By Francesca Bruce

Legal experts warn, however, that new Mexican procurement rules are discriminatory and could be challenged in the courts.

More from Policy & Regulation

FDA’s Small Business Eligibility Process Gets Update Before New Fiscal Year

 
• By Elizabeth Orr

The US FDA has updated its guidance document on small business eligibility determinations for medical device firms. Industry observers urge companies to ask for the status early to avoid any potential hold-ups.

Bipartisan Senate Bill Would Give Patients ‘True Price Tag’ Prior To Care

 
• By Brian Bossetta

Pending legislation seeks to address what the sponsors argue is a lack of transparency in medical billing. If enacted, the bill would provide patients with the costs of procedures and medications before receiving them. A data collection expert discusses what the bill could mean for patients.

How Notified Bodies Would Like Future EU Medtech Governance To Pan Out

 
• By Amanda Maxwell

Notified bodies are calling for their key role, as the technical, regulatory and clinical ‘extended arm’ of regulatory authorities, to remain central to the EU medtech conformity assessment process.