‘No Simple Formula’: US FDA Decisions On Surrogate Endpoints Are Complex, Case-Specific

Office of New Drugs’ Peter Stein runs down the types of evidence and other considerations weighed in determining that a surrogate is reasonably likely to predict clinical benefit; however, some panelists at a National Academies meeting say the agency needs to increase transparency around its thinking on surrogates that can support accelerated approval.

Math formulas
The FDA has no simple formula for determining whether a surrogate endpoint is reasonably likely to predict clinical benefit. • Source: Shutterstock

US FDA Office of New Drugs director Peter Stein attempted to explain at a recent National Academies meeting on accelerated approval how the agency determines that a surrogate endpoint has been deemed reasonably likely to predict clinical benefit.

More from Approval Standards

Device-Like System Proposed For Low-Risk Human Cell Therapies, Tissue-Based Products At US FDA

 
• By 

A risk-based approach to human cell therapies and tissue-based products could incentivize development and prevent bad actors from taking advantage of the current FDA system.

US FDA Under Makary: MAHA With A Lighter Touch

 

US FDA Commissioner nominee Martin Makary is being embraced by industry, and Senate Democrats, as a more traditional pick than other Trump Administration nominees, but the Make America Healthy Again agenda still is clearly coming to the agency.

New EU Approvals

 

The Pink Sheet's list of EU centralized approvals of new active substances has been updated to include four new products, one of which is Vimkunya, Bavarian Nordic's chikungunya vaccine.

Unfreezing US FDA: Generic Drug Officials Make Plea For Public Workshops

 

The FDA generic drugs team’s first public workshop of the second Trump Administration ended with a request that industry amplify the value it finds from public engagement.

More from Pathways & Standards

EMA Considers Whether Intrathecal Zolgensma Deserves Fast Tracking

 

Novartis is planning to file EU and US marketing applications for an intrathecal formulation of its spinal muscular atrophy gene therapy, Zolgensma, in H1 2025.

Surrogate Endpoint ‘Reasonably Likely’ Decision Process An ‘Uncertain Standard,’ Industry Says

 
• By 

The FDA’s accelerated approval draft guidance has left stakeholders seeking clarification of the process for determining a surrogate marker or intermediate clinical endpoint is reasonably likely to confirm clinical benefit.

Device-Like System Proposed For Low-Risk Human Cell Therapies, Tissue-Based Products At US FDA

 
• By 

A risk-based approach to human cell therapies and tissue-based products could incentivize development and prevent bad actors from taking advantage of the current FDA system.