JNJ, BMS’s IRA Loss Is First Time Court Rejects Industry’s First Amendment, Takings Claims

The fourth court loss for pharma in industry's attempts to kill Medicare’s drug price negotiation program adds to the list of reasons courts have rejected legal challenges to the Inflation Reduction Act.

toddler making a mess eating spaghetti
Pharma has thrown a lot of spaghetti at the wall in its IRA fight, but so far nothing has stuck. • Source: Shutterstock

Janssen Pharmaceutical Cos. and Bristol Myers Squibb Company failed to convince a district court judge that the Inflation Reduction Act’s drug price negotiation program violates the drug industry’s First Amendment rights, the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment or the Unconstitutional Conditions Doctrine, per a summary judgement issued in favor of the government 29 April.

The opinion from Judge Zahid Quaraishi of the United States District Court in the District of New Jersey, adds...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on Pink Sheet for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Litigation

Access Risks Loom For All Drugmakers With Fourth Circuit Mifepristone Decision

 

The FDA law establishing REMS authority does not preempt a West Virginia law that would restrict mifepristone use in the state, an appeals court said, a decision that could have broader ramifications for the agency’s authority to ensure drug access.

US FDA Will Not Pull Teva And MSN Hetlioz ANDAs, Rejects Vanda Citizen Petitions

 
• By 

The FDA concluded that generic tasimelteon products held by Teva and MSN Labs meet all statutory bioequivalence requirements and there was no “mistake” or untrue statement in the original ANDA approvals.

Clinical Trial Diversity Action Plan Guidance Must Return To US FDA Website, Court Says

 
• By 

HHS and its agencies violated the law by swiftly implementing “sweeping and poorly thought-through directives that ordered the bulk removal of healthcare resources,” including FDA draft guidances on diversity action plans and sex differences in clinical trials, a federal court said.

US Supreme Court Wants Solicitor General Input On Hikma Skinny Label Case

 
• By 

The US Supreme Court is seeking the administration's view following the Federal Circuit decided to reopen Amarin’s case against the ‘skinny-label’ generic Vascepa (icosapent ethyl).

More from Legal & IP

EU Fines Alchem Over Buscopan API Cartel

 
• By 

After pursuing Alchem International for breaches of EU antitrust rules – relating to a cartel over the SNBB pharmaceutical ingredient used in Buscopan and its generics – the European Commission has now hit the firm with a €489,000 fine.

Clinical Trial Diversity Action Plan Guidance Must Return To US FDA Website, Court Says

 
• By 

HHS and its agencies violated the law by swiftly implementing “sweeping and poorly thought-through directives that ordered the bulk removal of healthcare resources,” including FDA draft guidances on diversity action plans and sex differences in clinical trials, a federal court said.

Lawyers Weigh In On ‘Sunshine’ Clause In EU Pharma Reform Package

 

The Council of the EU has not taken forward a proposal from the European Parliament that would require companies to disclose the transfers of value they make to health care professionals and health care organizations – lawyers weigh in on the diverging proposals.