Animal Models: Adcomm Exposes Internal Rift In How FDA Defines ‘Translational’ For Purposes Of Confirmatory Evidence

FDA review staff consider the animal models used in development of US WorldMeds’ eflornithine for neuroblastoma to be translational to humans, even though this does not align with the definition in a September 2023 draft guidance on types of confirmatory evidence.

Mouse in lab
The translatability of mouse models to humans was critical to ODAC's view on the acceptance of such data as confirmatory evidence. • Source: Shutterstock

The recent advisory committee review of US WorldMeds, LLC’s eflornithine (DFMO) in high-risk neuroblastoma exposed an apparent difference of opinion between US FDA reviewers and a recently issued draft guidance on the use of animal model data for confirmatory evidence.

More from US FDA Performance Tracker

US FDA’s Review Performance Held Steady Despite Stormy First Quarter

 

Organizational turmoil has not yet affected reviews of novel agent applications, with Q1 2025 approvals coming in low, but the first quarter share of the entire year is variable.

‘Pipeline In A Pill’ Or Pipe Dream? US FDA’s April Goal Dates Test Expansion Strategies

 

Sanofi’s Dupixent, Amgen’s Uplizna, and Bristol’s Opdivo seek new indications, while J&J hopes to start a franchise with nipocalimab and Stealth’s day of reckoning approaches.

US FDA’s March Approval Candidates Take Aim At Established Markets

 

March features nearly 20 user fee goal dates, including a crowd of novel candidates for crowded areas like hemophilia, heart disease and urinary tract infections, as well as the potentially first therapies for a rare eye disease and hyperphagia of Prader-Willi syndrome.

GSK’s Penmenvy, Bavarian Nordic’s Vimkunya Clear US FDA, Will CDC Follow?

 

The US FDA approval of new meningococcal and chikungunya vaccines arrived in time for the 26-28 February meeting of the CDC’s Advisory Committee On Immunization Practices, if political developments allow.

More from Regulatory Trackers

EU CHMP Opinions And MAA Updates

 

This is an update of recommendations from the European Medicines Agency's Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use on the authorization of new medicines in the EU, and updates on EU marketing authorization changes recommended by the CHMP.

US FDA’s March Approval Candidates Take Aim At Established Markets

 

March features nearly 20 user fee goal dates, including a crowd of novel candidates for crowded areas like hemophilia, heart disease and urinary tract infections, as well as the potentially first therapies for a rare eye disease and hyperphagia of Prader-Willi syndrome.

EU Decision Time For Topical Gene Therapy Beremagene Geperpavec And Five Others

 

The European Medicines Agency is set to issue opinions this week on whether pan-EU marketing approval should be granted to a number of new products.