Could Government Negotiated Prices Curtail Access? PBMs And Potential Perverse Incentives Dominate First Medicare Listening Session

Patients and advocacy groups tell Medicare they want lower cost drugs but are concerned that if government negotiations lower list prices, rebate-focused PBMs may preference higher list-price competitors. 

CMS patient listening meena
CMS deputy administrator Meena Seshamani opened the listening session. • Source: Screenshot

Patients and patient advocates raised a potentially concerning paradox at the first Medicare public listening session on the drugs that will be subject to US government price negotiations under the new Inflation Reduction Act – that the government’s ability to get lower list prices for selected drugs might lead pharmacy benefits managers to make the medications more inaccessible to patients.

More from Pricing Debate

Think Tank Suggests CMS, USTR Could Enforce Most Favored Nation, Other Drug Pricing Policies

 
• By 

A Republican think tank suggested variations of the Most Favored Nation and international reference policies in Medicare and Medicaid, as well as tariffs and other trade levers to rebalance drug pricing disparities between US countries and abroad.

CMS Nominee Oz Nears Confirmation Despite Concerns About Medicaid Cuts

 
• By 

Democrats opposed the nomination because they believe Mehmet Oz will not defend Medicaid from spending cuts. His pledge to continue lowering drug costs in Medicare and Medicaid did not offset the concerns.

Branded Pharma And Generics Industries At Odds Over UK VPAG Framework

 

The UK branded drug industry is calling for adjustments to be made to the UK voluntary scheme framework for branded medicines, after the payment rate increased to 22.9% for 2025. Meanwhile, the generics industry says the scheme is functioning “as intended” and opposes any changes.

‘Hope And Scientific Spillover’ – Cross-Atlantic HTA Alliance To Focus On Novel Benefits

 

An initiative run by health technology appraisal (HTA) bodies in the US, Canada and England is looking at how non-traditional treatment benefits, such as the value of hope and scientific spillover, can inform appraisals and understanding of a product’s value.

More from Market Access

PBMs Must Prepare For Revival Of Drug Price Transparency Requirements

 

Experts say PBMs should become familiar with transparency rules and prepare to release data, although more legal wrangling could occur.

Is Optum Rx Payment Remodel To Favor Generics A Peace Offering For US FTC?

 

Optum Rx, one of the largest PBMs in the US, declared it was the “first comprehensive, transparent pharmacy services company” after announcing several consumer-friendly changes.

England’s NICE To ‘Explore’ Severity Modifier Changes As Cost-Effectiveness Threshold Branded ‘Ridiculous’

 

Health technology assessment body NICE said it has taken on feedback about the implications of allowing higher cost-effectiveness thresholds for some medicines after senior health economists offered diverging views on its methods.