The federal government lost one pharma case and won another in a pair of decisions issued last week. In a rare upset for the US Food and Drug Administration, an appeals court ruled against the agency’s interpretation of the Orphan Drug Act. And a district court threw out Pfizer Inc.’s complaint against the Department of Health and Human Services seeking a ruling that its proposed charity co-pay programs do not violate the Anti-Kickback Statute.
US FDA Loses Orphan Exclusivity Case While HHS Wins Dismissal Of Pfizer Kickback Complaint
In rare loss for FDA, appeals court reverses district court decision tossing Catalyst’s suit over Orphan Drug Act, saying deference should not have been granted to agency’s interpretation. District court finds it is too early to rule on one Pfizer charity co-pay program but backs broad reading of Anti-Kickback Statute.

More from Rare Diseases
Ascertaining the novelty and benefits of Makary’s new drug approval idea – along with what it would take to implement it – requires more clarity on the types of studies he envisions being used to grant and confirm “plausible mechanism’ approvals.
Industry feedback on a European Medicines Agency pilot that introduced a “stepwise” approach to pediatric investigation plans was positive, but the future of the new model will depend on the outcome of the pharmaceutical legislation negotiations, the agency says.
The hub’s goals of efficiency, centralization and coordination fit with the Trump Administration’s current focus for the FDA, Amy Comstock Rick, director of strategic coalitions, told the Biopharma Congress.
England’s health technology assessment institute, NICE, is looking to “reimagine” its evaluation process with the help of AI, rather than just using this technology to speed up its existing processes.
More from Pink Sheet
The International Council for Harmonisation has consolidated and modernized its existing stability guidelines into one document, and addressed modern stability testing approaches like modeling, bracketing, and matrixing.
A list of EU biosimilar filings, CHMP opinions and EU marketing authorizations, including details of the biosimilar company, the brand name/INN, indication(s), the reference product/company, and the date and type of event.
US CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices voted for harmonized meningococcal vaccine recommendations, while hearing updates about Sanofi’s pending supplemental MedQuadfi indication, AstraZeneca’s FluMist self-administration launch plans, and Lyme disease