'Natural' Plaintiffs Pivot From Mainstream Money To Category Pioneers

Mainstream personal-care brands using "all natural" claims have been the favored targets of plaintiff attorneys seeking settlement payouts, but now category pioneers including California Baby and Kiss My Face are under attack for softer "natural" claims – and they may be more inclined to defend their natural status, according to California-based attorney Angela Diesch.

In recent years, an almost surefire formula for plaintiff paydays has been to identify a personal-care company with deep pockets that's making 100% natural claims, comb through their ingredient lists to find one or more synthetic ingredients and sue them on a proposed class action basis for false advertising.

More from Legal

Uncertainty Abounds With SEC Climate Reporting Rule Tied Up In Courts

 
• By 

Despite questions surrounding the SEC rule, including disputes being litigated in the US Eighth Circuit, companies must prepare to meet the new climate disclosure requirements in addition to related mandates in California and abroad. Experts emphasize opportunities beyond compliance.

In Emergency Rule, California Bans All THCs In Hemp Products: Industry Asks, Where’s The Fire?

 

California authorities say predominance of retailers licensed to sell hemp are compliant with ban published effective on 3 October through emergency regulation. But hemp industry’s contesting the regulation in state court, arguing state authorities inappropriately used emergency action to change state law on hemp products legislature passed in 2021.

J&J Sued For ‘Plant-Based’ Claims On Aveeno, Neutrogena Makeup Removing Wipes

 
• By 

Plaintiffs in California federal courts seek restitution, damages, and other relief on behalf of themselves and consumers nationwide, whom allegedly were deceived by “Plant-Based” representations on Aveeno and Neutrogena Makeup Removing Wipes.

US FDA Action On Benzene Levels In Acne Products Demanded By New Citizen Petition

 
• By 

Filed on 20 August by Pensacola, FL-based law firm Aylstock, Witkin, Kreis & Overholtz (AWKO) on behalf of an unnamed client, the petition points to benzene study data unconnected to Valisure on unheated benzoyl peroxide products, but is light on details of how it was conducted.

More from Policy & Regulation

Oregon EPR Reporting Deadline Passes, But Non-Compliant Firms Have One More Shot

 

Single-use packaging producers subject to Oregon state’s Extended Producer Responsibility law that didn’t meet the 31 March deadline to report their packaging materials are given a grace period to report until 30 April, says Circular Action Alliance, the organization carrying out the EPR program.

German Industry Urges ECHA To Reconsider ‘De Facto’ EU Ethanol Ban

 
• By 

Reclassifying ethanol as a carcinogenic, mutagenic, or reprotoxic substance - something the European Chemicals Agency seems likely to do in the near future - would be “tantamount to a de facto ban” with “fatal consequences” for medical care in Germany, says Pharma Deutschland in a joint paper with 13 other German healthcare industry associations.

CA Prop 65: Personal Care Firms Wrestle With Listing Of Common Stabilizer, Packaging Material

 

Personal care companies selling in California that suspect they are subject to its listing of a common stabilizer and packaging material should collect Certificates of Analysis for all raw materials, pursue third-party formula testing and retain counsel.