FTC Targets Supplement Firm In Administrative Proceeding After Contempt Complaint Fails

Federal Judge Says Settlement Stipulation Against ‘Treats Disease’ Claims Is Ambiguous

A ruling in Maine federal court questions whether FTC could show firms made claims a product labeled as a supplement “cures, mitigates, or treats any disease." But agency's administrative complaint includes the same phrase as a stipulation among the penalties it would order.

The Federal Trade Commission pivots to an administrative proceeding in its litigation against a dietary supplement firm after a court ruled that terms US regulators commonly use to define noncompliant claims are vague and unenforceable as a stipulation in a settlement the FTC allowed the firm to enter.

After the FTC allowed Maine businesses Health Research Laboratories LLC and Whole Body Supplements LLC and their owner, Kramer Duhon, to enter a settlement in 2018 but filed a contempt...

Read the full article – start your free trial today!

Join thousands of industry professionals who rely on HBW Insight for daily insights

  • Start your 7-day free trial
  • Explore trusted news, analysis, and insights
  • Access comprehensive global coverage
  • Enjoy instant access – no credit card required

More from Compliance

Third-Party ‘Testing, Inspection and Certification’ Cleaning Up Amazon Supplement Market

 

Three FDA warnings related to supplement manufacturing, labeling or marketing submitted to Amazon or companies selling vitamin, mineral or supplement products on its e-commerce platform since April 2024.

Accelerating Natural Options Among US FDA’s Steps For Removing Petroleum-Based Food Dyes

 

HHS Secretary Kennedy commends food companies for cooperating, but also says, “We have them on the run now and we are going to win this battle. And four years from now, we're going to have most of these products off the market.”

Deleting Self-Affirmed GRAS Option Could Stretch FDA’s Already Thin Food Safety Resources

 

FDA introduced the option because it didn’t have sufficient staff to handle the volume of GRAS submission reviews requested by food and other firms for ingredients. Requiring submissions for all GRAS determinations “would just be an unworkable situation for the food industry if somehow submitting notice, submitting notices for FDA review and concurrence, was required,” says food and drug attorney Federick Stearns.

Traceability Rule Compliance Extended For Providers Of Herbals, Other Food Ingredients

 

FDA says “extension affords covered entities the additional time necessary to ensure complete coordination across the supply chain in order to fully implement the final rule’s requirements—ultimately providing FDA and consumers with greater transparency and food safety.”

More from Policy & Regulation

Supplementation Unlikely To Help With Hereditary Hair Loss, Says German Agency

 
• By 

Germany’s Federal Institute for Risk Assessment says that there is "no evidence that people with androgenetic alopecia have special dietary needs or a special nutrient requirement.”

NAD Asks FTC To Pull Bandage Off Firm’s Plan To Exhaust Inventory Using ‘2X Faster Healing’ Claim

 

After National Advertising Division attorneys, in a review prompted by a challenge by Band-Aid line marketer Kenvue, recommended ASO LLV cease use of its “up to 2x faster healing” claim, they determined the firm had not fully complied.

Supreme Court 1935 Ruling Limiting Executive Authority On Appointments ‘Unravels’ Today – DoJ

 

In complaint and response to motion to dismiss, Rebecca Kelly Slaughter’s and Alvaro Bedoya’s attorneys elaborate on Supreme Court ‘s 1935 decision, Humphrey’s Executor v. US. Administration attorneys, though, contend the ruling isn’t relevant to the current FTC.